An independent project ·Why this exists ·How this is made
Asheville · Western North Carolina
Step Up AVL
Myth vs. Fact ยท Asheville, NC

Five Myths About Housing and Hunger

The things we hear most about homelessness and hunger in Buncombe County, each one set against the county's own numbers. Sourced, dated, checkable.

Most arguments about who ends up on the street, or who runs out of food before the end of the month, run on assumptions about character. The data tell a steadier story, and it is mostly about arithmetic: what people earn, set against what they are charged for a roof and a meal.

Here are five things we hear often, and what the county's own figures actually say.

Myth 01

“People are homeless here because of addiction and mental illness.”

The fact

Not mainly. Addiction and mental illness are real, and they make it harder to stay housed. But they are not what sets the size of the problem. The 2026 Point-in-Time count found 824 people homeless in Buncombe County on a single night. Of them, 91 adults reported a mental-health condition and 62 reported a substance use disorder, both self-reported. The far larger force is a housing market with far too few homes the lowest-income renters can afford.

824
People homeless on one night, 2026 count
91
Reported a mental-health condition (self-reported)
62
Reported a substance use disorder (self-reported)
Myth 02

“If you hold down a job, you can afford a place.”

The fact

Not at the wages most jobs pay here. It takes about $35.29 an hour to afford a modest two-bedroom in the metro, and $32.19 for a one-bedroom. A single adult's living wage in Buncombe is $24.10 an hour. The median home price was about $500,000 in May 2026. A steady paycheck is not the same as an affordable one.

$35.29
Hourly wage to afford a 2-bedroom (metro)
$24.10
Single-adult living wage, Buncombe
~$500K
Median home price, May 2026
Myth 03

“They come here from somewhere else for the services.”

The fact

Most of the people living outside here didn't. Of the 824 people the 2026 Point-in-Time count found, 334 were living without shelter, and they were asked where they last had housing. About 60 percent said Buncombe County. Another 31 percent said somewhere else, and the rest did not answer. Some do arrive from elsewhere. No one was asked why they came. The shortage is the cause of homelessness, and the shortage was made here. Nationally, there are just 35 affordable, available homes for every 100 of the lowest-income renter households, so there is nowhere lower-cost to land.

35
Affordable homes per 100 lowest-income renter households (national)
Myth 04

“Food banks have hunger covered.”

The fact

Not on their own. Food banks are essential, and they cannot cover hunger alone. The numbers say why. About 25,000 Buncombe residents rely on SNAP, the federal grocery benefit, down from about 29,000 in 2025. When that benefit was held up in November 2025, during the federal shutdown, local charity could soften the blow but came nowhere close to replacing it. And SNAP itself does not reach everyone who struggles: an estimated 25 million food-insecure Americans, nearly half of them, likely earn too much to qualify.

~25,000
Buncombe residents on SNAP (2026)
25M
Food-insecure Americans likely income-ineligible for SNAP
Myth 05

“Hunger is a downtown problem.”

The fact

The map says otherwise. More than eight in ten of the U.S. counties with the worst food insecurity are rural. In Buncombe, about 16.8 percent of residents, roughly 46,200 people, are food insecure, the highest reading on record here. The federal survey these county estimates are built on was canceled in 2025. Feeding America plans to keep producing them by adding other data sources, so later readings would rest on a changed method. In most of the counties that border Buncombe, a larger share of residents get SNAP than in Buncombe itself, a pattern explored in Rural Hunger Is the Real Story.

8 in 10+
Worst-food-insecurity U.S. counties that are rural
46,200
Food-insecure Buncombe residents (16.8%, 2024)

The thread through all five: homelessness and hunger are set less by anyone's character than by how far local wages fall behind local rents and grocery bills. That shortfall is a policy choice, which means it can be changed.

The takeaway

Five claims, one test, and not one of them holds up.

When you read the local numbers instead of the stereotypes, the same cause keeps surfacing in two places: a housing market and a grocery bill that outrun local wages. Charity takes the edge off. It does not change the count. What changes the count is the homes we build and the benefits we fund. Five claims, one test, the county's own numbers, and not one of them holds up.

Sources & notes

For more information see: www.stepupavl.org

Asheville-Buncombe Continuum of Care 2026 Point-in-Time count (Feb 10, 2026; behavioral-health figures are single-source self-reports). The where-last-housed figures in Myth 03 come from the count's supplemental questions, whose answers cover only the 334 people counted without shelter: 200 (60 percent) said Asheville or Buncombe County, 103 (31 percent) said somewhere else (47 another North Carolina county, 42 another state, 14 no answer), and 31 (9 percent) did not respond (Asheville-Buncombe Continuum of Care, 2026 Point-in-Time Count Results). NLIHC Out of Reach 2026 (housing wage) and The Gap, 2026 edition (35 affordable homes per 100, national). Just Economics of WNC 2026 (living wage). Canopy MLS, via The Ruiz Report, May 2026 (median home price). NCDHHS FNS Caseload Statistics, July 2026 (SNAP enrollment, the about 25,000 figure); Buncombe County Health and Human Services, 2025 (the about 29,000 figure). Feeding America, Map the Meal Gap 2026, published July 28, 2026, using 2024 data (25 million income-ineligible, 48 percent; rural share 86 percent, 271 of 316 counties, national; Buncombe rate 16.8 percent, 46,200 people). The USDA terminated the Current Population Survey Food Security Supplement these county estimates are built on in September 2025, so official national and state food security data will not be available for 2025; Feeding America says it plans to keep producing local estimates by pairing the survey's historical state-level data with more recent state data from other sources, including the Behavioral Risk Factor Surveillance System.

Found an error? Tell us and we will correct it. The framing and conclusions here are our own.

Will YOU step up?

Every group in our directory is local, vetted, and doing this work right now. Pick one and back it. →